This article explores why everyone had been duped to think thread count is the only thing that matters when picking sheets

Why “High Thread Count” Is Overrated — And What to Look for Instead in Your Sheets and Comforters

For decades, high thread count has been the holy grail of luxury bedding. Like a Michelin star stamped on a pillowcase, it told shoppers, “This is the good stuff.” But here’s the truth: just because your sheets claim a 1,000 thread count doesn’t mean they feel (or perform) like a dream.

In fact, chasing numbers in bedding is a little like judging a book by how heavy it is. Sure, it feels impressive, but does it actually make your life better?

Thread Count ≠ Comfort

Let’s unpack the thread count myth—and what really matters when you’re building a bed worth sinking into.

🧵 What Even Is Thread Count?

Thread count = the number of threads woven into a square inch of fabric (both vertical and horizontal). So, 300 thread count means 150 threads in one direction and 150 in the other.

Here’s the catch: after about 400, you’re mostly being sold hype. Some manufacturers use double- or triple-ply yarns (twisting multiple threads together) to artificially inflate the number. It’s the bedding equivalent of stuffing your résumé with buzzwords.

“A 600-thread-count sheet made with multi-ply yarn is often lower quality than a 300-thread-count sheet made with long-staple single-ply cotton.” — Consumer Reports

🧪 The Feel Is in the Fiber

If thread count isn’t king, what is? Two things: fiber quality and weave type.

✅ What to Actually Look For:

  • Long-staple cotton (like Egyptian or Supima): stronger, softer, less prone to pilling.
  • Percale weave: crisp, breathable, perfect for hot sleepers or summer nights.
  • Sateen weave: smoother and silkier, with a gentle sheen—ideal for winter layering.
  • Linen or bamboo blends: naturally temperature-regulating and eco-friendly.

😬 I Fell For It

I once splurged on a set of 800-thread-count sheets because the packaging promised “hotel-level luxury.” What I got was more heat trap than sleep trap. The sheets were stiff, overly heavy, and started pilling after just a few washes.

Meanwhile, my 400-thread-count percale backup set? Breezy, smooth, and still going strong. I sleep cooler. I wash less. I complain less.

Lesson learned: higher isn’t always better—it’s just higher.

📊 The Stats Back It Up

  • 67% of consumers believe higher thread count equals better quality—but only 26% say those sheets actually feel better.
    (Source: Sleep Foundation survey)
  • Bedding brands that focus on fiber and weave over thread count report higher customer satisfaction.

🛍️ Recommended Picks

For the crisp sleeper:

Quince Organic Percale Sheet Set – Affordable, breathable, and surprisingly luxe for the price.

For the cozy cuddler:

Coyuchi Sateen Sheets – GOTS-certified, buttery-soft, and sustainable.

For the chill minimalist:

Brooklinen Linen Core Set – Pre-washed linen that gets softer with time.

For comforters that breathe:

💤 Final Thought: Shop With Your Skin, Not a Spreadsheet

At the end of the day (literally), the best bedding isn’t the one with the highest number—it’s the one you look forward to falling into. If it feels good, regulates your temperature, and holds up after washes, it’s a winner.

So skip the spec hype. Choose touch over tech specs. Because you’re not sleeping in numbers—you’re sleeping in sheets.

Back to blog